February 17, 2022   3 MIN READ

Prospects … Or Proven Talent?

ITB: Should Birds Make 3 1st-Round Picks Or Move Assets?


With the offseason underway, the Eagles have started planning to piece together a roster that they think can go further than last season.

On the latest Inside The Birds podcast, Geoff Mosher and Adam Caplan discussed personnel additions the Eagles need to make through free agency and the draft.

Howie Roseman

Eagles VP of Football Ops Howie Roseman has tough roster decisions ahead

Eagles Defense

Adam Caplan: “This is coming from other teams: When they look at the Eagles’ defensive roster they shake their head, they just don’t think there’s a lot of talent there. Obviously, the linebackers are a problem. Steven Nelson’s contract is up. [Darius] Slay is a stud, no doubt about it. Safety is a problem, linebacker is a problem, D-end is a problem. They just don’t have enough depth. They need talent upgrades. I would argue they’ve got a lot more work to do on defense than they do on offense. Some might not see it that way. Just on a talent level man, they need some upgrades.”

Trading Picks?

Geoff Mosher: “I think there’s a pretty good case to be made for maybe packaging two picks to move up in the first round if you see an elite prospect who is supposed to be picked in an area where maybe that prospect has fallen. Instead of sitting there and trying to make 15, 16 and 19 – or maybe even moving down with a pick to add – if you feel like there’s a good cluster the second round.

“Obviously the Eagles have a lot of different options here. I don’t think they’re going to make three first-round picks. I think they’re going to move around. I think it’s hard to say right now, it all depends on what happens, whether they go up, they go down, they go out. We have a lot to determine between now and the draft.”

Caplan: “On that, what we’re also told on these things is that it’s what the board tells you. So let’s say they’re at 19, right? And every player at 19 is gone, you’re definitely going to want to look to trade out. If at 19 the next player on your board is a second-round pick you’re looking to do everything you can trade out.”

Top 5 GM?

Caplan: “My opinion would be no, because he’s not consistent enough in the draft. If he was at least above .500 in the draft – he’s won a Super Bowl, has been really good at free agency and does good contracts. He doesn’t always get it right with contracts, but he does a good job. He would be a top-five GM, but he’s not because of his draft picks, he just has to do better. He’s got to continue to listen to Andy Weidl and the personnel staff and go by their board that is set. [Also], listen to his man Tom Donahoe. If he does that, this thing’s gonna move forward.”

– Justin Morganstein (@jmotweets_) is a staff writer for InsideTheBirds.com.

Listen to the latest “Inside The Birds” podcast from Geoff Mosher and Adam Caplan here:

Or watch on YouTube:

About The Author

Comments are closed here.